John,

How about writing that the installation is non-professional and should be evaluated by a qualified roofing contractor.

I do not recognize caulk as a roofing material. I do not see it in quality installations and would not tell my client to put faith in such conditions. Whenever I see caulk on a roof I comment on it. To me it raises a question - why is it there?

I've seen leaks from roofs that look great. So you can bet that I'm going to question an install that seems anything less.

__________________
Eric Barker
Moraine Woods Consulting, Inc.
Barrington, IL