Thom,
One of the problems Mike just ran into is that, when one exposes the way they did something to prove it was the correct way, they expose that installation and previously unseen and not accessible areas to the viewer.
In showing us the peel-and-stick flashing around the windows, this is now visible (from the guide you linked to):
(bold and underlining are mine)
-
GAPS & SEALANTS
- - Seal all gaps with a high-quality, paintable sealant with a stated service life of 30 years. Follow the sealant manufacturer’s instructions for application and backer rod requirements. (Jerry's note: Typically, this means a 1/4" or so gap for the backer rod, then the caulking. On the next page I see they are specifying a minimum 3/16" gap for lap siding. I do not see where a backer rod was used.)
- Flashing, Windows, Doors & Openings
- -
All openings must be sealed, caulked and/or flashed in a manner that prevents moisture intrusion or water buildup. Several examples that accomplish this are shown on the following pages. (Jerry's note: Such as on the top of the window.)
- Finishing instructions
- - DO
- - - Paint all siding surfaces including drip edges (to me, that means to paint the cut edge above the top of the window and the cut edges beside and under the window)
- LP SmartSide Panel Siding
- - I see where either method of horizontal joints is acceptable, the 'Z' flashed one and the stepped out method. I am assuming that the stepped out method was used as I can see the studs and the bottom plate along that edge.
- - Self-Flashing Windows - Shows a trim around the window which is foam or putty sealed to the siding, however, in the photos, the untouched windows do not have any trim around them.
"DEVIATION FROM SIDING APPLICATION INSTRUCTION REQUIREMENTS VOIDS WARRANTY"
That's what it says.
Did the inspector make the right call? As Thom said "I think the Inspector may have made an understandable, but not necessarily correct call."
HOWEVER, in making that incorrect call (incorrect because the windows are - 'appear to be' - self-flashing), the inspector made the correct call because the siding was not installed properly (which the inspector did not know).
The problem, as I see it, is that while verifying the self-flashed windows and peel-and-stick flashing were done, other problems were exposed. Problems which will exist all the way around the house at each applicable location. Problems with the siding installation which are not in accordance with the installation instructions and which will take considerably more work to correct.
I wish my 'mistakes' would end so 'positive'. 