Originally Posted by
William Mize
What is the appropriate repair, My thinking is replacement of the shingles.
Yes, replacement of those shingles, all of them with an exposed nail, even if only part way exposed.
And, of course, replacement of any and all shingles damaged during those repairs. Which not only includes breaking, cracking or tearing of shingles being lifted, but of shingles damaged by the roofer's boots from kneeling down and making the repairs (if not careful, the toes of their boots will damage the shingles below and they will not even think of looking down to see if they damaged those shingles).