Guess I really messed that statement up with "does not jive" as I meant it in how we (where I was) used "jive" when growing up where "jive" had several meanings, including "does not jive" = "does not make sense" - but alas, that is all lost in dictionary definitions.

What I should have done was simply said what I mean: "Something just does not add up in there, does not make sense."