Thoughts on this

[dan orourke]

.........

[Phillip Stojanik]

The work certainly is not pretty by any stretch of the imagination but I do not see a significant functional problem with this. If the alternative is to have the rafter end just floating out there then I will take the 2-by filler material instead and just mumble under my breath about it.

[Mike Huppi]

We do not see any of the foam on the sheathing in the Portland Oregon area. Do you have much problems with moisture under the foam?

[Phillip Stojanik]

The shiny material on the underside of the roof decking is not a foam product; its a radient barrier which is just a foil product glued to the plywood or OSB.

[Bruce Breedlove]

It's not pretty. Luckily a few feet away the rafter is supported by a post which is in turn supported by a beam.

Without knowing what is on the other side of the rafter it's hard to say what the loads are at the end of the rafter. It would have been nice if the framers had at least nailed a block between the joists below the 2X4 for additional support.

It is certainly questionable. Hard to say whether to recommend a repair without knowing more.