water heater straps

[cory wright]

Please verify my logic. these water heater straps will not hold the unit in place as intended because they are wrapped backwards. in order to hold the unit in place they need to be wrapped the opposite way. I could find no wording addressing the direction of the straps. Here is how i wrote it up, suggestions welcomed.
Water Heater
· Safety Issue: Repair: Water heaters in seismic zones should be anchored or strapped to resist movement during earthquake conditions. Although this water heater is strapped it is not strapped properly. It is OK to wrap the straps completely around the unit, however the strap cross section should be at the front of the unit, not the back. The unit can still fall forward the way it is currently strapped. See ca.gov website for details: http://www.oes.ca.gov/Operational/OESHome.nsf/PDF/EQ%2014%20tips/$file/water_heater.pdf (http://www.oes.ca.gov/Operational/OESHome.nsf/PDF/EQ%2014%20tips/$file/water_heater.pdf)

[Daniel Leung]

Yes, the installation is wrong. See instruction on the attached photos.

[Dave Wheeler]

if the straps are strong enough and bolted into the beams it looks like it should hold. We don't have problems like that in New York so we don't see that.

[Brandon Whitmore]

Did you grab and shake it to simulate an earthquake?:D

[Wayne Carlisle]

There are several more violations with this installation. Is the strapping the only thing you are worried about?

[Bob Harper]

There are several more violations with this installation. Is the strapping the only thing you are worried about?

sediment trap
TPR drain
clearance btw vent and insulation on water lines
vent connection to draft hood
drain pan- a leak would ruin that drywall platform
protection of that gas line? Appears exposed
for starters

[cory wright]

sediment trap
TPR drain
clearance btw vent and insulation on water lines
vent connection to draft hood
drain pan- a leak would ruin that drywall platform
protection of that gas line? Appears exposed
for starters

Thanks Bob,
correct no sediment trap present/accessible.
The TPR line goes through the wall to the exterior and discharges into a flowerbed at appropriate height.
clearance between the insulation and vent is indeed insufficient
can you elaborate on the vent connection to draft hood? is it the tape that makes it wrong?
the platform is cement board and this WH is in the garage. this is new construction and all are installed this way. not saying it's right, but it is accepted by the AHJ and is the norm, would you still suggest calling it out?
what would you suggest to protect the exposed gas flex line. again this is the norm in these parts, all new contruction does it this way and i would be calling this out on every inspection.

in reply to dave-the straps in their current configuration would not hold the WH in place, the tension is on the wall side of the tank. this tank could slide away from the wall because the way the staps are wrapped.