Vent flashing

[mathew stouffer]

How do you write this up? Flashing/cap improperly installed and fabricated on site.

[A.D. Miller]

Amateur flashing insulation should be improved. At a minimum a high-grade low-modulus sealant should be applies to the make-shift storm collar.

[mathew stouffer]

But we all agree it is an incorrect installation. I am being accused of being too picky.

[Jerry Peck]

I am being accused of being too picky.


Tell them that "too picky" is when you note that the oil canning on the roof below is an eyesore and therefore the roof below is in need of replacement. :D

Then tell them that, oh, by the way, this chimney cap is all bit to crap and needs to be replaced while they are up there replacing that gas vent cap. That ought to tweak their nose up a bit. :eek:

[Billy Stephens]

Tell them that "too picky" is when you note that the oil canning on the roof below is an eyesore and therefore the roof below is in need of replacement. :D

.
.
for The Benefit of The Folks South of The Freeze Line.
* I believe that is called Snow. ;)
.
.

[mathew stouffer]

Yes, that is snow and we did not get much of it this year. But in the past that is what has beat the crap out of the cap Jerry;)

[Jerry Peck]

Tell them that "too picky" is when you note that the oil canning on the roof below is an eyesore and therefore the roof below is in need of replacement. :D


for The Benefit of The Folks South of The Freeze Line.
* I believe that is called Snow. ;)


I saw that white fluffy stuff on the ground, but I figured that if it was snow on the roof, at the depth of the snow on the ground the standing seams on the roof would not be visible ... :p

After a good high wind event, metal panel roofs look just like that from oil canning. And, if you look at the other roof to the left you will actually see SNOW (that white fluffy stuff) on it, and, ... it looks just like the roof I am referring to. :p

But - Mat was there and he said it was snow on that roof, so ... I gotta go with what the man who was there says. :)

[Billy Stephens]

.
I saw that white fluffy stuff .....
.

.
.
:D Thanks For Clearing that up. :D
.
.

[mathew stouffer]

Sorry Jerry, I was talking about the stuff on the ground. What were you talking about.

[Gunnar Alquist]

Matthew,

I think that JP is referring to the dented standing seam metal roof in the background. I would guess that "oil canning" is what happens to sheet metal when you throw an oil can at it.

[Bob Harper]

You would need to know the listed requirements of both appliances venting here. First of all, does this gas vent meet the separation requirements of the chimney to the right, which appears to be a factory built fireplace. Next, ditto the gas to the wood. Does the gas vent require their flashing to be ventilated-most wood does. Does the B-vent listing rely on the flashing for top support or can you/ is there a lower support that meets the listing requirements? Most vents require a 2" raised lip above the "roof", then a storm collar with caulk to the vent. Does this chase top termination meet the 3/2/10 for the Fp?

If that is a EPDM rubber roof coating, it is a problem. If it is metal, it appears to be kinked and possibly a problem.

Yes, you need to consider snow drifting on top of chases. Ugly neighbor's roofs are not addressed by the codes but by knuckles. ;-)


Sloppy workmanship is not in and of itself a problem as long as it meet the functional requirements. Show where it is a defect or it must stand.

HTH,
Bob

[John Kogel]

Matthew,

I think that JP is referring to the dented standing seam metal roof in the background. I would guess that "oil canning" is what happens to sheet metal when you throw an oil can at it.I think the practice you're referring to there is "beer canning". :)

Old-timers like JP know that engine oil used to come in cans. You shoved a spiggot with a sharp cutter into the top of the can and flipped that into the filler hole on the old oil-burner engine while the leaded gas was pumping. The suction of the oil glooping out thru the spout caused the walls of the can to collapse a bit, then it would gasp a little air and pop out, etc. that's "oil-canning". :)

[Billy Stephens]

.
"oil canning".
.
The Term is Most Often used to Described Buckled Vinyl Siding.
.
www.certainteed.com/resources/cts205.pdf (http://www.certainteed.com/resources/cts205.pdf)
.

[ray jackson]

I don't know what the complaint is. I'm sure the home owner paid good money for that "custom" flashing. I bet if you look at all the other roofs around you won't see another like it.:D

[Jerry Peck]

I think that JP is referring to the dented standing seam metal roof in the background.

Correct.


Old-timers like JP know that engine oil used to come in cans. You shoved a spiggot with a sharp cutter into the top of the can and flipped that into the filler hole on the old oil-burner engine while the leaded gas was pumping. The suction of the oil glooping out thru the spout caused the walls of the can to collapse a bit, then it would gasp a little air and pop out, etc. that's "oil-canning". :)

Correct. :)

The metal roof panels are installed nice, and flat, and purty, then along comes a strong wind and ... it tries to suck the metal panels off the roof by pulling against the flat areas and tugging against the clips holding the standing seams down, which leaves a not-so-purty-any-more metal panel roof with wrinkles along the flat part of the panels.

[Markus Keller]

If you are being called 'too picky', you have reached great inspector status.
Congratulations.:)

[H.G. Watson, Sr.]

Is this cap & flashing sitting on a chimney pot on the roof? I can't make out with the lighting (& old eyes) despite blowing up photo (shadows?).

Seems proximity no matter what is being served is an issue with vent on the right as BH pointed out.

[Stuart Brooks]

I don't know about the rest of you but sometimes I get tired of being diplomatic and considerate in phraseology. Don't you ever want to just say, "It's a bunch of crud!. Just tear it down and get someone more qualified than the village idiot to replace it!"

[Jerry Peck]

I don't know about the rest of you but sometimes I get tired of being diplomatic and considerate in phraseology. Don't you ever want to just say, "It's a bunch of crud!. Just tear it down and get someone more qualified than the village idiot to replace it!"

Yes, and ...


... many times I have said stuff just like that. :D

My clients really like it. :cool: