Results 1 to 17 of 17
Thread: Transfer Switch
-
04-14-2017, 01:03 PM #1
Transfer Switch
Country property. A backup portable generator is temporarily connected to a panel that controls a limited number of circuits in a home. Clearly, they don't want to purchase a huge generator for intermittent use. Typical backup generator scenario in my area. Intended for a day or two while the power is out.
The transfer switch was unusual (for me). This involved two double-pole circuit breakers installed back-to-back with a mechanical link that will only allow one breaker to be "on". Ok, so that is how a transfer switch should work - it will isolate the panel from the utility (disconnect from PG&E) in favor of the generator or will connect to the utility and disconnect from the generator. But, I normally see a separate transfer switch box, not this mechanical device between breakers.
So (finally), my question is: Is this an approved transfer switching method? It doesn't look jury-rigged. It looks like a device manufactured specifically to be used as a transfer switch. I just have not seen this before.
Similar Threads:Department of Redundancy Department
Supreme Emperor of Hyperbole
http://www.FullCircleInspect.com/
-
04-14-2017, 02:52 PM #2
Re: Transfer Switch
Does this only serve the few circuits in the lower part of the panel? If so I don't see an issue and there is no interconnect between the utility and generator.
- - - Updated - - -
Does this only serve the few circuits in the lower part of the panel? If so I don't see an issue and there is no interconnect between the utility and generator.
All answers based on unamended National Electrical codes.
-
04-14-2017, 03:06 PM #3
Re: Transfer Switch
Thanks for replying Jim,
Yes, a feed was run from a 50 amp breaker at the service equipment to one side of that strange doubled-up breaker setup in this panel (the generator feed ran to the matching breaker). These few branch circuit wires were protected by breakers in this panel, then run back and spliced in to the original conductors at the service equipment. The neutral and equipment grounds never left the service equipment.
I run into backup generators and transfer switches fairly regularly. The thing is that I often see permanent backup generators setup with automatic transfer switches that detect a power outage, kick on the generator and flip the transfer switch. When a portable generator is used, I either see a dedicated transfer switch in its own box (like a knife switch) or I see it done way wrong with labels that say "turn this one off" and "turn this one on". Oy!
I was mainly asking if this was an "approved" setup rather than something jury-rigged. It looked like a manufactured device specifically for this use. But, I have not seen one of these before.
Department of Redundancy Department
Supreme Emperor of Hyperbole
http://www.FullCircleInspect.com/
-
04-14-2017, 06:01 PM #4
Re: Transfer Switch
My initial reaction is ... I like that and I'm going to look into doing that at my house.
If you choose not to decide, you still have made a choice.
-
04-14-2017, 06:58 PM #5
Re: Transfer Switch
Ditto, that setup is legit so long as the loads in that panel do not exceed the max provided by the feeder and the breaker in the main panel.
There is another style I have seen where a large panel board has a split buss with the lower end controlled by a manual transfer switch.
John Kogel, RHI, BC HI Lic #47455
www.allsafehome.ca
-
04-14-2017, 07:02 PM #6
Re: Transfer Switch
Gunnar,
Do you have a better photo of that MTS label?
That may very well be a listed device, but I can't tell by that photo, and I couldn't find a similar manual transfer switch with a Google search.
First appearances is that it looks okay, load management may be an issue, something you might want to point out (the 50 amp main and feeder capacity to that panel is being replaced by a 30 amp ... it is likely that not all circuits will be working on the emergency generator supply.
A bigger issue may be the neutrals (lack of) for the 120 volt circuits going from that panel back to where they are spliced - the circuit neutrals need to run with the circuit hot conductors wherever the circuit hot conductors go. That flexible metal raceway may get a bit warm from the eddy currents with no neutrals run with the hot conductors.
Of course, though, that may likely require a larger raceway as the number of conductors will increase.
-
04-15-2017, 10:45 AM #7
Re: Transfer Switch
Hi Jerry,
I do not have a better pic of the label. Sometimes I remember to take label specific pics and sometimes I don't . I will try to remember to take more specific pics in the future.
I ended up deferring on this. Primarily because researching this type of system could take a couple of hours. Really beyond the scope of a regular home inspection.
Department of Redundancy Department
Supreme Emperor of Hyperbole
http://www.FullCircleInspect.com/
-
04-21-2017, 01:46 PM #8
Re: Transfer Switch
Here is a link to the mechanical type lockout.
http://www.interlockkit.com/
-
04-21-2017, 06:36 PM #9
Re: Transfer Switch
Something seems a little funny about that, Richard.
There's nothing wrong with Met Labs, from anything I've seen or heard.
However, the fact that they specify compliance with UL 67, the standard for panelboards, only with regard to installation and mechanical operation, makes me wonder what the device's classification doesn't cover.
Usually, if something such as a CB is classified for use in panelboard X, this means that it's operating characteristics are equivalent to or at least compatible with what's in the panel, just as much as the items listed in the panel alongside the schematic and ratings.
- - - Updated - - -
Something seems a little funny about that, Richard.
There's nothing wrong with Met Labs, from anything I've seen or heard.
However, the fact that they specify compliance with UL 67, the standard for panelboards, only with regard to installation and mechanical operation, makes me wonder what the device's classification doesn't cover.
Usually, if something such as a CB is classified for use in panelboard X, this means that it's operating characteristics are equivalent to or at least compatible with what's in the panel, just as much as the items listed in the panel alongside the schematic and ratings.
-
04-22-2017, 05:18 AM #10
Re: Transfer Switch
Did they make the breaker?
I would think that the breaker would already be a listed item.
-
04-22-2017, 05:27 PM #11
-
04-22-2017, 06:39 PM #12
Re: Transfer Switch
As an inspector, my question to the contractor would be this: provide a letter from the manufacturer of the panelboard stating that this device does not negatively affect their panelboard.
That's like my solution for damaged trusses:
- Step One: Get an engineer's letter stating what needs to be done.
- Step Two: Get an engineer's letter stating that what needed to be done was actually done.
-
04-23-2017, 09:28 AM #13
Re: Transfer Switch
In one way it is, in one way it isn't:
The engineer is motivated by being hired to write the first letter, and motivated by being hired to re-evaluate, and seeing that his specs were met, to write the second.
I don't see what would necessarily motivate the panelboard manufacturer to sign off on some other manufacturer's product.
-
04-23-2017, 11:20 AM #14
Re: Transfer Switch
-
04-24-2017, 08:30 AM #15
Re: Transfer Switch
Thanks Richard, David and Jerry,
I had not even thought about the brand compatibility and approval issue. I am going to bring these pics and your observations to my next chapter meeting. Should be interesting.
Department of Redundancy Department
Supreme Emperor of Hyperbole
http://www.FullCircleInspect.com/
-
04-24-2017, 09:02 PM #16
Re: Transfer Switch
How is the manual transfer switch different from any automatic switching device, such as those you are used to seeing?
The transfer switches we see here, just as many manual as automatic, appear to be manufactured by the major companies, Schneder, Generac, or Kohler. Any violations would be in incorrect installation, IMO.
This is from the GE installation manual.
"The InterLock Kit will only allow one of these breakers to be in the “ON” position meeting the requirements of Article 702 of the National Electric Code ANSI/NFPA 70. The installation of the breaker retaining strap meets Article 408.36 (NEC 2008). "
Last edited by John Kogel; 04-24-2017 at 09:16 PM.
John Kogel, RHI, BC HI Lic #47455
www.allsafehome.ca
-
04-25-2017, 05:59 AM #17
Re: Transfer Switch
The devil's in the fine print. If I saw a Schneider device mounted on a Square D panel, I would expect it to be fully compatible, but even so I might check with Schneider. If it was a GE device, I might not expect Schneider to be as forthcoming about its suitability for use with their panel. Sometimes legalese seems to just be precision, but when I see "Classified as suitable only with respect to," or whatever the words Gunnar read were, I want to check. Because I'm ignorant.
Bookmarks